ContraCostaLive.com  ·  SPOTLIGHT Program

What Are 20 New Customers
Actually Worth to Your Restaurant?

The math most restaurant owners have never sat down to do — and why it changes everything about how you think about marketing.

You already know these people.
You just haven't met them yet.

Think about the 10 or 15 regulars who make your week. The couple that comes every Thursday. The family that always requests the same table. The solo diner who tips 30% and knows your whole staff by name.

Every single one of them was once a stranger who walked through your door for the first time.

The SPOTLIGHT program is built to turn strangers into exactly those people. Not one-time deal chasers. Not coupon clippers. Genuine, loyal customers you'll look forward to seeing walk through your door.

If this program delivers 20 to 40 of them — what does that actually mean for your restaurant? Let's do the math.

A full table of diners at a Contra Costa restaurant — new customers rarely dine alone
Look at that table. That's not one customer — that's $110, $220, maybe $330 walking through your door.

Step 1: What Is One Visit Really Worth?

Before we get to lifetime value, let's start with what actually happens when a new customer walks in — because they rarely walk in alone.

🔑 The Insight Most Restaurant Owners Miss

When you acquire one new customer, you're not getting one person at one meal. You're getting a table. They come as a couple, a small group, or a family. The average party size at a sit-down dinner is approximately 2.5 people.

At an average of ~$45 per person, that's not a $45 visit. That's a $110 table — every single time they come in.

1 new customer acquired ≈ $110 per visit, not $45

Step 2: How Often Do They Come Back?

Not every new customer becomes a regular — and that's fine. When you look at a realistic mix, even occasional visitors add up remarkably fast.

👋

The Occasional Visitor

~50% of new customers  ·  2–3x per year
$220/yr
Lifetime value (5–7 yrs): $1,100–$1,500
📅

The Regular

~30% of new customers  ·  6–8x per year
$660/yr
Lifetime value (5–7 yrs): $3,300–$4,600
❤️

The Loyal Regular

~20% of new customers  ·  12–20x per year
$1,650/yr
Lifetime value (5–7 yrs): $8,250–$11,500

Step 3: The 20-Customer Value Table

Using the realistic customer mix above — here's what 20 new customers delivered by SPOTLIGHT actually means for your business.

📊 20 New Customers · Full Value Breakdown

Customer Type Count (of 20) Annual Value Each Annual Total Lifetime Total
Occasional (2–3x/yr) 10 $220 $2,200 $11,000–$15,000
Regular (6–8x/yr) 6 $660 $3,960 $19,800–$27,700
Loyal Regular (12–20x/yr) 4 $1,650 $6,600 $33,000–$46,000
TOTAL — 20 New Customers $12,760/yr $63,800–$88,700
Occasional (2–3x/yr)
Count
10
Annual each
$220
Annual total
$2,200
Lifetime total
$11,000–$15,000
Regular (6–8x/yr)
Count
6
Annual each
$660
Annual total
$3,960
Lifetime total
$19,800–$27,700
Loyal Regular (12–20x/yr)
Count
4
Annual each
$1,650
Annual total
$6,600
Lifetime total
$33,000–$46,000
TOTAL — 20 New Customers
Annual total
$12,760/yr
Lifetime total
$63,800–$88,700

Example assumptions: $45/person · 2.5 party size · adjust to match your restaurant. Does not include word-of-mouth referrals, which can add 20–40% more on top.

The $3,245 Question

SPOTLIGHT costs $3,245 per year — $62.40 a week. Here's how many new customers it takes to justify that investment at every level.

6
New customers to break even annually
Just 6 new tables a year and the program pays for itself. That's roughly one new customer every 8 weeks.
2
Loyal customers to break even on lifetime value
Two loyal regulars alone justify the entire annual investment based on lifetime spend.
10:1
Lifetime ROI with just 10 new customers
10 new customers = ~$32,000 in lifetime value against a $3,245 spend. Most marketing can't come close.
20:1
Lifetime ROI with 20 new customers
At 20 new customers, SPOTLIGHT becomes one of the best financial decisions in your entire operation.

Good Investment vs. Absolute No-Brainer

Where does SPOTLIGHT fall on the scale? Here's the simple version.

How Many New Customers = What Outcome?

6

New customers
Break Even
Program pays for itself in year one

10

New customers
Great Investment
~$32K lifetime · 10:1 ROI

20+

New customers
Absolute No-Brainer
~$65K+ lifetime · Why would you ever cancel?

If SPOTLIGHT delivers even 10 new tables in a year, canceling it would be one of the most expensive decisions you make. The math doesn't lie.

Why Not Just Run a Deal or Discount?

Not all customer acquisition is equal. The type of customer you attract matters as much as the number.

✗ Discount-Based Marketing

  • Attracts deal-seekers, not loyal customers
  • You pay 30–50% of an already discounted check
  • Trains customers to only return for deals
  • Destroys the perceived value of your brand
  • No data, no list — no long-term asset built
  • Can cost $5–15 in margin per customer acquired

✓ SPOTLIGHT Marketing

  • Attracts experience-seekers who pay full price
  • You control the offer — at full margin if you choose
  • Creates urgency without damaging your brand
  • 7,000+ engaged locals with 70% email open rates
  • Builds a subscriber list you own forever
  • Unique links/codes — track clicks in GA4 + measure redemptions

Restaurants That Have Trusted SPOTLIGHT for 5+ Years

These aren't test drives. These are restaurant owners who looked at the math, started the program, and never looked back.

5+ Years
Cap's Restaurant
Brentwood, CA
5+ Years
Celia's Mexican Food Restaurant
Antioch, CA
5+ Years
Smith's Landing Seafood Grill
Antioch, CA
5+ Years
Vinnie's Bar
Concord, CA
5+ Years
19th Hole Casino & Sports Bar
Antioch, CA

Five years of renewals is the only testimonial that matters. These owners know their numbers.

Ready to Meet Your Next 20 Regulars?

Those 20 to 40 customers you'll look forward to seeing are out there right now — they just haven't found you yet. Let's fix that for $62.40 a week.

Ready to commit? Choose your entry point below:

We only take one new restaurant partner per month. Reach out before the spot fills.